Apple iPhone 17 Pro

Throne Score · 1.2.0
4.0/5Good Eco Score
Ethics findingUnethical practices80% evidenceThe evidence documents serious harmful practices or failures linked to this business. Read who is harmed and the dated sources below.

Eco Score breakdown

77% evidence · Moderate evidence
These parts are the Eco Score. The ethics finding is separate and is not a second number.
Repairability & longevity82.7%
Excellent Eco Score85% evidence
Recycled materials56%
Moderate Eco Score100% evidence
Circularity100%
Excellent Eco Score100% evidence
Carbon & packaging64.9%
Good Eco Score100% evidence

Ethics report

This is separate from the Eco Score. The public report shows no Ethics number: documented harm cannot be cancelled by a better policy elsewhere. Unknown facts reduce evidence coverage; they are never silently marked as ethical.
Ethics findingUnethical practices80% evidenceThe evidence documents serious harmful practices or failures linked to this business. Read who is harmed and the dated sources below.

These findings are separate from the Eco Score. The public report shows no Ethics number.

Claims vs evidence

Title

Apple FY2024 carbon-credit claim check

Status

Partially verified

Claim

Apple's 2025 Environmental Progress Report says it retired 737,100 tonnes of carbon credits for FY2024: 666,800 tonnes against corporate emissions and 70,300 tonnes against product life-cycle emissions.

Finding

The report's arithmetic reconciles internally. Public Verra retirement records contain exact project-and-vintage volumes matching the reported Chyulu Hills, Guinan and Apepu quantities, but the matching entries do not publicly name Apple as beneficiary. The reported 78,507-tonne Arbaro Forestal San Pedro figure does not cleanly reconcile to a corresponding public retirement total in the reviewed registry records. Apple links to project pages rather than specific retirement certificates or serial ranges.

Unresolved

The public trail does not fully establish Apple attribution for the matching project retirements or reconcile the Arbaro quantity. This check also does not establish that the credits are additional, durable or equivalent to avoiding the original emissions.

Scope

Apple corporate and selected product life-cycle emissions for FY2024; this is not a product-level finding for every iPhone.

Checked

2026-09-12

Related Report Label

Read HTT's full Arbaro investigation

Read source Read source Read source Read source Read source Read source

Who is harmed?

Group

Plantation workers

Affected

Workers handling fumigation and other plantation operations in Paraguay

Event Date

2021 fieldwork

Harm

Field research at Forestal Apepú reported 56 plantation workers, with ten assigned to daily fumigation. It describes the employment created by the plantation model as limited, temporary, precarious and potentially dangerous.

Scope

Direct fieldwork concerning Forestal Apepú and communities around Apepú and Forestal San Pedro in 2021; it does not establish every worker's exposure or current conditions.

Read source Read source
Group

Children & families

Affected

Children and families living around Paraguay's industrial plantation landscape

Event Date

2021 fieldwork; HTT review checked 2026-09-12

Harm

Routine fumigation work and reported agrochemical pollution of water and soils create exposure risks for nearby families. HTT's Arbaro investigation also records documentary allegations about schools near spray zones and children's health that require project-level and medical verification.

Scope

Arbaro-area fieldwork establishes fumigation and reported water/soil pollution. The reviewed records do not establish medical causation for a named child or prove that every documentary allegation concerns the exact Apple-linked retirement.

Read source Read source
Group

Local communities

Affected

Peasant and Indigenous communities around Forestal Apepú and Forestal San Pedro

Event Date

2021 fieldwork

Harm

Field interviews report land disputes, pressure to leave or sell land, community division, shrinking livelihood options and reduced food sovereignty as eucalyptus plantations occupy large areas.

Scope

Direct 2021 fieldwork with residents around the two Arbaro investments in Paraguay. Interview testimony is evidence of reported impact, not a court judgment covering every parcel.

Read source Read source
Group

Water, soil & wildlife

Affected

Water cycles, soils, native vegetation, insects, birds and other wildlife

Event Date

2021 fieldwork; Arbaro reporting year 2023

Harm

Large eucalyptus monocultures are associated in the reviewed field report with hydrological stress, nutrient and soil damage, agrochemical pollution and sharply reduced biodiversity. Arbaro's own report confirms thousands of hectares of eucalyptus plantations in Apepú and San Pedro.

Scope

Project-area and regional plantation evidence. It does not mean every hectare has identical impacts, and Arbaro reports conservation areas and environmental-management measures that must also be considered.

Read source Read source Read source
Group

Indigenous defenders

Affected

Qom land defenders and communities resisting eucalyptus plantations in Paraguay

Event Date

Threats and assault documented in 2020–2021

Harm

Amnesty International documented the assault of Qom leader Bernarda Pesoa after she opposed eucalyptus-plantation work on community land where proper free, prior and informed consent had not been obtained.

Scope

Important Paraguayan eucalyptus-plantation context from HTT's investigation. This case concerns a Fundación Paraguaya project, not Forestal Apepú, Forestal San Pedro, Apple or an Apple carbon-credit retirement.

Read source Read source Read source
Group

Climate & future generations

Affected

People and ecosystems bearing the consequences of emissions that carbon credits claim to neutralise

Event Date

Apple FY2024 credit claim; checked 2026-09-12

Harm

If a forestry credit overstates additional carbon storage, or stored carbon is later lost through harvest, burning or fire, the original emissions remain in the atmosphere while the buyer reports them as offset. The reviewed public registry trail also does not fully reconcile Apple's reported Arbaro quantity.

Scope

A carbon-integrity risk and unresolved evidence gap, not a finding that every credited tonne has already failed or that all tree-planting projects are equivalent.

Read source Read source Read source Read source
Group

People

Affected

Artisanal miners, children and their families in the Democratic Republic of the Congo

Harm

Cobalt extraction can involve hazardous, life-threatening work, child labour, unstable income and weak access to remedy.

Scope

Electronics-sector risk. It is not proof that cobalt in this exact device came from an abusive mine.

Read source
Group

Mine-affected peoples

Affected

Workers, Indigenous peoples and communities across cobalt, copper, lithium, nickel, rare-earth and 3TG supply chains

Harm

Electronics mineral supply chains can carry intertwined risks involving labour rights, armed conflict, corruption, land, water, pollution and taxation. A recycled-content percentage does not by itself prove that the remaining primary material is harm-free.

Scope

Sector-wide critical-minerals risk covering more than cobalt. Exact attribution requires mine, processor, smelter and chain-of-custody evidence for the device.

Read source Read source
Group

Children & e-waste workers

Affected

Children, pregnant workers and families working or living near informal electronics recycling and dumpsites

Harm

Unsafe e-waste recycling can release lead, mercury, cadmium, flame retardants and other toxic substances. WHO links exposure with lifelong neurological, respiratory, reproductive and other health harms, and estimates millions of children and women may be at risk.

Scope

Global end-of-life sector evidence. It is not proof that this exact discarded device reached a named dumpsite; company take-back, repair and verified downstream recycling evidence is assessed separately.

Read source Read source Read source
Group

Repairers & consumers

Affected

Device owners, lower-income households and independent repair businesses

Harm

Parts pairing, software locks, unavailable manuals or parts and repair-hostile design can raise costs, reduce choice and push working products toward replacement. The FTC found scant evidence for many broad manufacturer justifications for repair restrictions.

Scope

Sector and market evidence, especially mobile devices. The listing's repairability and parts evidence shows whether this product and manufacturer reduce or reproduce that harm.

Read source
Group

Users & civil society

Affected

Users, journalists, activists, dissidents and communities disproportionately targeted by surveillance

Harm

Devices, platforms and private surveillance technologies can enable tracking, censorship, harassment and interference with privacy, expression, association and assembly when safeguards and accountability fail.

Scope

Technology-sector human-rights risk. A company is marked only where its policies, product conduct, contracts, enforcement records or documented use establish responsibility.

Read source Read source
Group

Civilians & targeted communities

Affected

Civilians, humanitarian workers and communities affected by military, intelligence, policing or occupation-linked technology

Harm

Drones, cloud services, communications, AI and surveillance systems can contribute to targeting, repression or denial of essential services. Those consequences must be shown alongside any documented corporate contract or deployment.

Scope

Sector-level pathway, not an allegation against every electronics brand. Company attribution requires evidence of a relevant contract, system, use or failure of human-rights due diligence.

Read source Read source
Group

Communities receiving waste

Affected

Communities and ecosystems where discarded electronics are dumped, burned or processed without adequate controls

Harm

The world generated 62 million tonnes of e-waste in 2022 and only 22.3% was documented as properly collected and recycled. Uncontrolled disposal can pollute air, soil, aquifers and drinking water while transferring health costs to communities with the least protection.

Scope

Global sector evidence. A brand's downstream responsibility depends on verified collection volumes, reuse, recycler standards and export or disposal records - not the existence of a take-back webpage alone.

Read source Read source

Company findings

Label

Workers & human rights

Pillar

Workers & human rights

Question

Does the company prevent forced and child labour, protect worker voice and safety, and provide remedy when harm occurs?

Summary

KnowTheChain scored Apple 52/100 for action and disclosure on forced-labour risks. The scorecard also records supply-chain forced-labour allegations; a score is not a finding that the chain is abuse-free.

Scope

Company and global supply chain

Source Date

2022

Read source
Label

Conflict minerals & Congo

Pillar

Conflict minerals & Congo

Question

Can the company trace high-risk minerals, show independent due diligence, improve conditions in the DRC, and remedy harm rather than merely avoid it?

Summary

Amnesty traced cobalt from hazardous DRC artisanal mining through processors toward battery makers reported to supply Apple and found that brands could not establish that their cobalt was free of child labour. Apple later led the reviewed companies on due-diligence improvement, but disclosure gaps remained. Current 3TG filings establish a system, not mine-to-device cobalt traceability, a named fatality link or proof of remedy.

Scope

Company due-diligence system; not physical traceability of this phone

Source Date

2016 / 2017 / 2025 / 2026

Read source Read source Read source Read source
Label

Privacy & digital rights

Pillar

Privacy & digital rights

Question

Does the company protect privacy, freedom of expression and users from surveillance, censorship and abusive data practices?

Summary

The 2026 World Benchmarking Alliance Ranking Digital Rights assessment scores Apple 44/100 across governance, freedom of expression and privacy.

Scope

Company policies and practices

Source Date

2026

Read source
Label

Corporate conduct & accountability

Pillar

Corporate conduct & accountability

Question

Does the company act transparently on tax, lobbying, corruption, discrimination and misconduct; do its public claims reconcile with underlying records; and does it provide meaningful accountability and remedy?

Summary

The 2026 World Benchmarking Alliance Social Benchmark scores Apple 39.8/100 on fundamental expectations for human rights, decent work and ethical conduct.

Scope

Company-wide

Source Date

2026

Read source

About Apple iPhone 17 Pro

Materials and composition

Recycled Fibre

100% recycled or responsibly sourced fibers (includes bamboo)

2 more fieldsUnlock

Free account · 5 full reports a month

Unlock the full Apple iPhone 17 Pro record

Check the audit before you buy. A free account opens 5 full reports a month, and reports you have already opened stay open.

Free · No credit card · Unlocks immediatelyAlready a member? Sign in

Included in your free reader pass

  • The full product table, row by row
  • The recorded finding on every Apple iPhone 17 Pro record
  • Parent ownership and certifications
  • 2 boycott lists checked

Ratings from other sources

Saved directory results, each on its own scale. These are separate from the Throne Score.

DirectoryTheir resultScale and source
Tom's Guide4/5Star rating out of 5 (performance and value, NOT sustainability)

Notes: Editorial performance review: speed, screen, battery, camera, value. Does not assess materials or repairability.


Directory assessment date 2025-09-17
Checked 2026-08-24
Read directory source
Good On YouGood On YouTom's Guide: 4/5

Represent this business? Provide missing evidence or request a correction. Source evidence and independent authority review are required.