Natural framing; L'Oreal-owned (2025 sell-back to founder)
| Ingredient transparency | Full ingredient list read and categorised |
| Ownership | L'Oreal (divestiture to founder-led partnership announced 2025) |
| Where made | No public disclosure found, the brand is headquartered in New York. |
| Cruelty free | No |
| Vegan | Partial |
| Organic | No |
| Certifications | None major; ingredient transparency |
| Sold in mainland China | No, the brand states products are not tested on animals anywhere including mainland China and it is PETA certified. |
| Palm oil | Good On You's assessment records that all of its palm oil is RSPO certified. |
| Good On You | Rated Good overall by Good On You, with Good for planet and It's a Start for people. |
| EWG | No EWG Verified status found. |
| External ratings | Good On You 'Good' |
| Controversies | Faced sustained sell-out backlash and formula-cheapening complaints after the 2014 L'Oreal acquisition, which founder Lisa Price has publicly denied. |
| Caveat | Ownership changed in 2025 when L'Oreal USA divested the brand to entrepreneur Joe Wong with founder Lisa Price taking an equity stake and the president role, so L'Oreal-era palm, mica and climate commitments may no longer apply. |
| Reports note | <p>No COAs; parent China sales caveat; landmark Black-founded</p> |
Why there is no score: Partial read. This verdict is provisional. Only part of the catalogue could be read and the certifications listed have not been checked against the certifiers own registers, so the evidence does not yet support a settled verdict. No score is published. Ingredient lists were obtained for 5 products, but the brand's product listing did not respond when the total catalogue size was measured, so the share of the range covered is unknown. Without a denominator a percentage would be meaningless.
Last checked 22 July 2026.
Not yet independently verified. The certifications listed for this brand are as the brand states them. They have not yet been checked against the certifiers own registers, so they should be read as a claim rather than a confirmed fact.
We analysed 5 Carol’s Daughter products, categorising every listed ingredient by function, origin (raw natural, naturally derived or synthetic) and safety concern. This is not the whole catalogue, so it is reported as a partial read. Percentages show the share of each formula that is natural or naturally derived.
Coverage: Ingredient lists were read for 5 products. The size of the full catalogue could not be established, so no average is shown.
Analyst note: Ingredient lists were read for 5 products. The brand's total catalogue size could not be measured, so the share of the catalogue covered here is not known.
| Product | Natural | Ingredients | Flagged |
|---|---|---|---|
| Born To Repair Reviving Hair Oil with Shea Butter | 100% | 11 | 0 |
| Mimosa Hair Honey Shine Pomade | 100% | 10 | 0 |
| Hair Milk Refresher Spray | 100% | 16 | 0 |
| Black Vanilla Moisture & Hold Jelly | 100% | 8 | 0 |
| Goddess Strength 7 Oil Blend Hair & Scalp Oil | 100% | 11 | 0 |
Full ingredient breakdown
The full ingredient by ingredient breakdown of all 5 Carol’s Daughter products (56 ingredients, each categorised by function, origin and safety concern) is free with an account.
Create a free accountAlready have one? Log in